3 was amazing, i loved the aspect of playing from 4 (badguys included) different aspects of the same story, you really get a feel and understanding of who the characters are and why they do what they do. However those who have 1 & 2 claim that they are even better, which is quite intriguing. Sadly, 4 did not grip me at all. 5 However shows good promise, I'm a bit o ways through it now, yet i have trouble picking it back up, but i seem to be that way with all rpgs lately.